Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam > Blaise Pascal Instituut > Girard Studiekring > COV&R 2007 > Abstracts Papers 

Kornél Zathureczky

Christianity, Islam and reason: Pope Benedict XVI and Tariq Ramadan

Email - Profile - Subtheme # 3

ABSTRACT

A recent speech of Pope Benedict XVI in Regensburg elicited a flurry of violent protests among many Muslims throughout the world. Benedict appealed to the Greek philosophical heritage of Christianity which the latter appropriated through the theology of the Logos, locating Christianity’s essentially non-violent disposition within this doctrine. While Benedict advocates the necessity of a mutual relationship between faith and reason, he also implies that this relationship between the two is an exclusive achievement of Christian theology in Europe. In the spirit of theological dialogue, mistakenly perceived as disdain for the prophet Muhammad, the Pope questions whether Islam’s perceived connection to violence may not be attributed to a deflated role of reason in Islamic theology. He insinuates that this lack may be the biggest obstacle to accepting the presence of Islam in Europe. 

We look at a response to the Regensburg speech, offered by Tariq Ramadan, most well-known for his work in construing an idea of specifically European Islam, as a significant achievement of theological dialogue, one that not only engages the real substance of the Pope’s speech but also challenges its theological presuppositions.  Ramadan’s immediate response to the Pope’s speech and to the vehemence of Muslim response may be found at: http://www.digitalnpq.org/archive/2006_fall/05_ramadan.html

----------------------------------------

Kornél Zathureczky, Postdoctoral research Fellow Université de Montréal Chair of Islam, Pluralism, and Globalisation 1556 Boulevard St-Joseph Est Montréal, Québec H2J 1M7 514-232-4666

 

    SITEMAP Girard Studiekring